2023 Cowboys rookie class snap counts fell way short of most previous rookie classes

A few days ago, our own David Howman posted his 2023 Cowboys rookie report in which he took a look at the contribution of the 2023 rookie class. And I’m not spilling any secrets when I say that that contribution was nothing to write home about.

There are many different ways of evaluating the impact, success, and quality of a rookie class, though most of them in some form or another revolve around early impact and the number of starters drafted.

In any rookie class, you’re looking for immediate contribution from your early picks, and perhaps hoping for some additional contribution from your late-round picks. In the medium term, it’s widely held that a good draft class yields two solid starters, even if they are not necessarily expected to be starters in their first season.

For our purposes today, we’ll use the 2023 rookie class snap count to evaluate their first-year contribution and to compare this class to previous rookie classes.

The 2023 draft class combined for 1,385 snaps on offense and defense over 18 games, which adds up to 5.2% of all Cowboys offensive and defensive snaps over those 18 games. That’s pretty low, even accounting for the season-ending injuries suffered by some of the draft picks. But the number of starts is eyebrow-raisingly low for this draft class, with just five starts across all rookies.

So how do the snap counts above compare to those of previous rookie classes? The title of this post already gave it away, the snap counts for the 2023 rookie class fall way short of most previous rookie classes. Here are the Cowboys rookie class snap percentages since 2007:

For this analysis, let’s assume that adding the equivalent of two starters (or 9.0% of all snaps) to the roster is a good target for a rookie class. By that measure the data here suggests the Cowboys had some really bad draft classes between 2007-2012, but things started looking up in 2013, and have been mostly green since Will McClay took over the Cowboys drafts in 2014, the occasional glitch (2019) notwithstanding.

But the 2023 draft class is the worst since at least 2019 and possibly the worst since the infamous “special teams draft” of 2009. The Cowboys gave up their 2019 first-round pick for Amari Cooper, and if I were to add his snaps to the 2019 total, that snap percentage would climb to 5.8%. Not much better than the 2023 class, but better. So does the 2023 class still count as a glitch, or is it more than that?

It’s not looking good so far, but it’s still too early to tell of course. It takes more than a weak rookie season to determine the value of a draft class. Three years (and sometimes even more) is the standard often used to fully evaluate a rookie class. Which is why we’re now going to look at how the snap percentages of each season’s rookie class have progressed over the years.

The snap data I have available only goes back to 2007, which leaves some gaps in the table below, but that’s probably as far back in Cowboys history as we’d want to go anyway.

What this allows us to do is look at how different rookie classes performed in terms of snap percentage in each of their first five years in the league, which I’ve summarized in the table below. To make the table easier to read, it is color-coded as follows